Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology

Balancing the Religious Connotations of Nativity Scenes and State Neutrality

by David Katz Rotnitzky

Question(s) at stake

Whether the display of a nativity scene in the entrance hall of a public school and the use of Catholic religious symbols in a school activity titled “Deck out your classroom for Christmas”, constitute a violation of a teacher’s rights to equality and freedom of religion.

Outcome of the ruling

The Court dismissed the appeal concerning the request to remove the nativity scene from the entrance hall of the public high school. It concluded that neither the display of the nativity scene in the school’s common areas during the Christmas season nor the voluntary activity “Deck out your classroom for Christmas” violated the fundamental rights invoked by the appellant.

Country:

Spain

Official citation

High Court of Justice Murcia, Judgement of 30 October March 2009, No. 948/2009 (Tribunal Superior de Justicia Murcia, Sentencia de 30 de octubre de 2009, Sentencia núm. 948/2009)

ECLI:ES:TSJMU:2009:2269

Topic(s)

Keywords:

State-funded schools State neutrality Teachers Participation in religious activities Static religious symbols

Tag(s):

Nativity scene Educational ethos Religious freedom of teachers Christmas traditional symbols

Bibliographic information

Katz Rotnitzky, David (2026): Balancing the Religious Connotations of Nativity Scenes and State Neutrality, Department of Law and Anthropology, Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology, Halle (Saale), Germany, CUREDI100ES012, https://doi.org/10.48509/CUREDI100ES012.

About the authors

David Katz Rotnitzky (Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology, Department Law and Anthropology, Germany) ORCID logo

Portrait picture of David Katz Rotnitzky

David Katz is a PhD Candidate in the Law & Anthropology Department at the Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology in Halle. He holds a bachelor’s degree in social and cultural anthropology from the University of Barcelona (Spain), and was awarded the European Master’s Degree in Human Rights and Democratization by the European Inter University Centre in Venice (Italy), for which he spent a semester at the UNESCO Chair on Education for Human Rights, Democracy and Peace at the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki (Greece). In his master’s thesis, “Deconstructing the Right to Freedom of Religion or Belief in Human Rights: A Multidisciplinary Approach on Antisemitism towards the Jewish Community of Thessaloniki”, he analysed the right to freedom of religion and belief and the correlation between the inherent antisemitism in some spheres of Greek society and the limits on the enjoyment of religious rights by the Jewish community of Thessaloniki. His current research falls within the project “Cultural and Religious Diversity under State Law across Europe” (CUREDI).