Religious Affiliation as a Challenge to Judicial Independence: A Case Study of II KK 440/23
by Juliusz Mroziński
Question(s) at stake
Whether a judge’s axiological connection with the Catholic faith and the Catholic Church constitutes grounds for recusal from hearing a criminal case concerning offences involving the insult to the religious feelings of Roman Catholics and the insult to an object of religious worship.
Outcome of the ruling
Circumstances indicating the judge’s axiological connection with the Catholic faith and the Catholic Church – evidenced by a clerical recommendation submitted during the nomination procedure and by a volume of poetry published by the judge – may, from the perspective of an objective observer, give rise to reasonable doubts as to the judge’s impartiality in a case concerning criminal liability for offending the religious feelings of Roman Catholics and insulting an object of religious worship, and may therefore constitute grounds for the judge’s recusal.
Country:
Official citation
Supreme Court, Decision of 27 March 2024, II KK 440/23 (Postanowienie Sądu Najwyższego z dnia 27 marca 2024 r., II KK 440/23)
Topic(s)
Keywords:
Freedom of thought, conscience and religion Defamation of religion / blasphemy Monuments
Tag(s):
Offence against religious feelings Public insult to an object of religious worship or a place of religious worship Desecration of a monument or public place commemorating a historical event or honouring a person Judicial religious impartiality